Papaya salad recipes look fairly straightforward on paper. Shred some green papaya, crush a few chillies, add lime, fish sauce and sugar. What could go wrong?
Quite a bit, as it happens. Too much pounding and the papaya loses its crunch. Too much fish sauce and the dressing overwhelms everything else. Even the size of your mortar can make a difference to how you prepare it.
We looked at four approaches to making Som Tum: recipes from Hot Thai Kitchen, Marion's Kitchen and RecipeTin Eats, alongside the version our Head Chef Rin grew up with in Isan, northeastern Thailand.
They share plenty of ingredients, but the way each cook handles them is worth exploring.
Chef Rin's papaya salad: From an Isan village to Doncaster
Papaya salad was part of everyday life in the village where Rin grew up. It was made at home, shared with family and eaten alongside other Isan dishes, often with plenty of chilli.
The recipe she uses today comes from those childhood experiences. Making it was never about following measurements from a cookbook. The garlic and chillies were pounded in a mortar, the vegetables added, and the dressing adjusted until it tasted right.
Cooking the same food in Britain has meant making a few changes.
Some of the vegetable varieties commonly used in Thailand are difficult to find here. Others are available through specialist suppliers but can be expensive. Rin uses more accessible alternatives where they work, paying particular attention to the crunch of the finished salad.
She has also made a conscious decision about pla ra.
This fermented fish seasoning is a familiar part of Isan cooking. It has a powerful smell and a deep, salty flavour that many Thai people grow up enjoying. For customers who aren't familiar with it, though, that aroma can be quite a surprise.
Rin leaves pla ra out of the standard Som Tum she serves at Charm Thai Cafe. She uses fish sauce, fresh lime, palm sugar and chilli to bring the flavours together. A pla ra version is available on request at the restaurant.
It's a recipe with its roots in her home village, adjusted to work with ingredients available in Western countries and to suit the people she now cooks for.
A few things Rin does differently
Watch Rin prepare Som Tum and you'll see that she doesn't spend ages pounding the papaya.
She peels the unripe fruit, shaves it into strips with a knife and works it through the dressing using a wooden pestle and spoon. The pestle bruises the vegetables lightly while the spoon helps turn everything together.
She tastes the dressing as she goes. A little more lime, perhaps, or a touch of palm sugar. The amount depends on the ingredients and the person ordering.
Her restaurant version contains no dried shrimp. Roasted peanuts are served separately, and customers can choose their chilli level, including no chilli at all.
The papaya should still have a bite when it reaches the table. If it's gone soft and limp, it's been worked too hard.
Chef Rin's Papaya Salad Recipe.
Hot Thai Kitchen: A lesson in using the mortar
Pailin Chongchitnant at Hot Thai Kitchen takes time to explain the technique behind making Som Tum.
Her green papaya salad recipe uses garlic, chillies, palm sugar, long beans, dried shrimp and peanuts, with fish sauce, lime and tamarind in the dressing.
The mortar does much of the work.
The wooden pestle bruises the ingredients while a spoon moves them around, bringing the vegetables and dressing together without crushing everything into a pulp.
Pailin also recommends giving the shredded papaya a soak in iced water to make it especially crisp. It needs draining and drying properly afterwards, otherwise the extra water dilutes the dressing.
There's advice for cooks using smaller mortars, too, which is useful when you don't have the deep clay or wooden mortar commonly used for Som Tum in Thailand.
If you're interested in learning how the pounding technique works, her explanation is well worth reading.
Marion's Kitchen: No mortar? Use a rolling pin
Marion Grasby's Som Tum recipe is easy to follow, particularly if you've never made papaya salad before.
Her ingredient list includes green papaya, dried shrimp, peanuts, beans, garlic, chilli, lime, fish sauce and white sugar.
The garlic, beans, dried shrimp, peanuts and chilli are bruised first. Papaya and dressing follow, with tomatoes added towards the end.
Marion also offers a practical workaround for anyone without a mortar and pestle.
Put the ingredients into a large zip-lock bag and gently bash them with a rolling pin.
It sounds a little unconventional, but it's a handy alternative if you don't fancy buying specialist equipment for your first attempt.
She also suggests ordinary green beans in place of Thai snake beans. That's useful advice for UK home cooks who have to work with whatever their local supermarket stocks.
RecipeTin Eats: Keep the papaya out of the mortar
Nagi Maehashi does something different in her green papaya salad recipe.
The dressing begins in a mortar, where garlic, chilli and dried shrimp are pounded before palm sugar, lime juice and fish sauce go in.
She bruises the beans separately and lightly crushes the tomatoes by hand. Then the ingredients are brought together in a mixing bowl.
The shredded papaya itself doesn't get pounded.
Nagi explains that the fine strips soften once they meet the dressing, so tossing everything together is enough.
It's a method worth considering if your papaya salad tends to end up wetter or softer than you'd like.
Her recipe also includes Thai basil and plenty of advice about finding suitable ingredients outside Thailand.
The little things that change the flavour
| Recipe | Equipment | Sugar | Dried shrimp | Papaya preparation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chef Rin | Deep mortar, wooden pestle and spoon | Palm sugar and brown sugar | No | Shaved with a knife; lightly bruised in the mortar |
| Hot Thai Kitchen | Mortar and pestle, with bowl method as an alternative | Palm sugar | Yes | Julienned; optional ice-water soak, then pounded and turned |
| Marion's Kitchen | Mortar and pestle, or a bag and rolling pin | White sugar | Yes | Julienned; lightly bruised with the other ingredients |
| RecipeTin Eats | Mortar for dressing; bowl for the salad | Palm sugar | Yes | Shredded and tossed in a bowl, without pounding the papaya |
Sugar is one difference worth paying attention to.
Marion uses white sugar, while Hot Thai Kitchen and RecipeTin Eats use palm sugar. Palm sugar brings a slightly caramel-like flavour, although the amount used matters just as much as the type.
Hot Thai Kitchen also adds tamarind, giving the dressing another sour note alongside the lime.
Dried shrimp appears in all three of those recipes. It adds a savoury seafood flavour, but it won't suit everybody, particularly anyone with a shellfish allergy.
Rin leaves it out of the version she serves at Charm Thai Cafe.
Then there are the regional differences.
Som Tum made in Isan can taste quite different from the sweeter versions often associated with Bangkok. Fermented fish, saltiness, chilli and sweetness all play their part, and family recipes vary.
Rin remembers the stronger, less sweet salads she ate growing up. The standard version she serves at the restaurant keeps the sharpness and chilli, without the fermented fish.
Finding the vegetables in Britain
Green papaya is probably the first obstacle for anyone attempting Som Tum at home.
You won't normally find it in the fruit section of a standard UK supermarket. Thai supermarkets and other Asian food shops are a better bet, although stock can be unpredictable.
Look for firm, unripe fruit with green skin. The soft, orange papaya you might buy for a fruit salad won't give you the same result.
Thai long beans can be another nuisance to track down.
Ordinary green beans are an acceptable substitute and much easier to find. Several of the recipes we've looked at make allowances for them.
Rin has an alternative for green papaya, too: turnip.
Shredded turnip has a firmness that works quite well with the pounding method, although its peppery flavour is different from the mild taste of green papaya.
RecipeTin Eats also discusses alternatives such as green mango and cucumber.
None will produce quite the same salad as unripe papaya, but they're useful options when the proper ingredients are unavailable.
So, which recipe would I start with?
If you've got a small mortar and don't want to buy anything else, RecipeTin Eats is a sensible starting point. Most of the mixing happens in a bowl.
Marion's Kitchen is handy for a first attempt without specialist equipment. Her rolling-pin method gets around one of the biggest obstacles.
Hot Thai Kitchen is particularly good if you want to understand how Som Tum is traditionally worked in the mortar. There is plenty of detail about the technique.
Rin's version comes from a different place. It's a village recipe she has carried with her from Isan, with practical changes made over the years to accommodate the vegetables available in Britain.
Her advice for anyone making it at home is to be careful with the fish sauce and not to pound the papaya too hard.
Those two things alone can make a noticeable difference.
A final tip from Rin
Make papaya salad shortly before you plan to eat it.
Once the dressing has been mixed through, the vegetables slowly release moisture and the papaya begins to soften.
Rin makes each portion fresh at Charm Thai Cafe. The crunch matters, and so does tasting the dressing just before it's served.
If you're having a go at home, you can follow Rin's full papaya salad recipe and cooking guide.
Or, if you're visiting Doncaster, try the version she prepares at Charm Thai Cafe on Copley Road.